Technical note on conducting mixedmethod evaluations quick advice for the usaid evaluation manager mixed method evaluation involves the systematic integration of different kinds of data, usually drawn from different evaluation designs. Experimental design, qualitative data, and content analysis. Abstract data integration is a crucial element in mixed methods analysis and conceptualization. Pdf the challenge in data analysis often lies in taking account of the multi dimensionality and complexity of the data and at the same time. Data from the qualitative and quantitative components can be integrated at the analysis stage of a mixed methods. Exemplars of mixed methods data combination and analysis. It navigates the reader through some of real world or hot topics within mixed methods including data analysis, integration. Parallelconcurrent mixed methods design data collection separate but concurrent. A truly mixed methodology incorporates multiple approaches in all stag es of the study. Data analysis and interpretation 357 the results of qualitative data analysis guide subsequent data collection, and analysis is thus a lessdistinct final stage of the research process than quantitative analysis, where data analysis does not begin until all data have been collected and condensed into numbers. The mixed analysis can be designed based, wherein it is directly linked to the mixed methods design e. A unique aspect of some mixed methods studies is the availability of both qualitative and quantitative data on the same cases.
The purpose of this methodological article is to provide a primer for conducting a mixed analysisthe term used for analyzing data in mixed research. Finally, we outline the types of research questions that are pertinent for each of these seven steps of the mixed methods data analysis process. Emergent data analysis techniques in mixed methods research. Understanding mixed methods research w ork on this book began almost a decade ago when we started writing about mixed methods research at the time that qualitative research had achieved legitimacy and writers were advocating for its use in the social and human sciences. Six mixed methods design strategies creswell, 2003 1. Broadly, when you try to integrate your data, one of three things can happen. Collecting data in mixed methods research r esearchers collect data in a mixed methods study to address the research questions or hypotheses. Levitt university of massachusetts boston michael bamberg clark university john w. However, integrating findings from different datasets can be one of the most challenging aspects of mixed methods data analysis. The apa publications and communications board task force report heidi m.
Integrating quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis while studying patientcentered medical home models. Data collection and analysis methods in impact evaluation page 2 outputs and desired outcomes and impacts see brief no. Pdf data analysis strategies for mixedmethod evaluation. Angela harden is a social scientist with expertise in public health and evidenceinformed policy and practice. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods what is the.
The contributors to this volume raise many questions about the meaning of triangulation, its philosophical positioning in the mixed methods community, and strategies for using triangulation in the design of mixed methods studies, analysis and interpretation of data, and making. Finally, we outline the types of research questions that are pertinent for each of these seven steps of the mixed methods data analysis. Combining qualitative methods combining qualitative. In general, mixed methods research represents research that involves collecting, analyzing, and interpreting quantitative and qualitative data in a single study or in a series of studies that investigate the same underlying phenomenon. As a methodology, mmr involves philosophical assumptions that guide the direction of the collection and analysis of data and the mixture of qualitative and quantitative data in a single study or series of studies. Data integration with new research technologies nigel g. Four integrative data analysis strategies for mixed method evaluation designs are derived from and illustrated by empirical practice. Three techniques for integrating data in mixed methods. Where appropriate, such integrative strategies are encouraged. Time constraints similarly, data complexity and quality affect the time needed for data collection and analysis. In so doing, we utilize onwuegbuzie and teddlies 2003 sevenstage conceptualization of the mixed methods data analysis process.
Best practices for mixed methods research in the health sciences embedding data. Data collection first data analysis new theory or hypothesis proposed not very structured sample size can be relatively small. Equal priority is given to the two phases but priority can be given to either. Data were collected in these designs to provide more data about results from the earlier phase of data collection and analysis. Journal article reporting standards for qualitative primary. Alternatively, the mixed analysis can be phase based, in which the mixed analysis takes place in one or more phases e. Graduate support department of research and innovation university of pretoria. Although many evaluators now routinely use a variety of methods, what distinguishes mixed method evaluation is the intentional or planned use of diverse methods for particular mixedmethod purposes using particular mixedmethod designs.
Qualitative data analysis is an iterative and reflexive process that begins as data. Purpose of the study the purpose of this sequential explanatory mixed methods study will be to study. Data combination and analysis techniques are presented using the following approaches. Understanding mixed methods research w ork on this book began almost a decade ago when we started writing about mixed methods research at the time that quali. Abstract data integration is a crucial element in mixed methods analysis. This design first begins with the collection and analysis of quantitative data and followed by the collection and analysis of qualitative data. It is part of a series commissioned by the agency for healthcare research and quality. Linking research questions to mixed methods data analysis. Current mixed methods practices in qualitative research. Mixed methods are used differently for evaluation designs with a dominant quant or qual orientation 11 table 2. Although technological innovations have shortened the time needed to process quantitative data, a good survey requires considerable time to create and. Mixed methods analysis and information visualization. The challenge in data analysis often lies in taking account of the multidimensionality and complexity of the data and at the. Multilevel mixed designs mehrebenen mixed methods design in these parallel or sequential designs, mixing occurs across multiple levels of analysis, as quan and qual data are.
The appropriateness of these strategies for different kinds of mixed method intents is then discussed. A synthesis after completing this chapter, you should be able to describe the decisions that a mixed methods researcher makes during. Primarily purpose is for gaining a broader perspective than could be gained from using only the predominant data collection method. Purposeful sampling for qualitative data collection and. The integration of quantitative and qualitative data in the form of a mixed methods study has great potential to strengthen the rigor and enrich the analysis. Mixed methods social inquirers choose from a full repertoire of methodological options at any number of multiple points in an inquiry process purpose, overall design, methods, sampling, data recording, analysis, and interpretation. Merging qualitative and quantitative data in mixed methods research. Methodology chapter of your dissertation should include discussions about the methods of data analysis.
Following my post last month about using concentric circles for gathering research data, i had a question from a reader. Leech n, onwuegbuzie a, 2008 a typology of mixed methods research designs. Using rigorous procedures in collecting and analyzing data appropriate to each methods tradition, such as ensuring the appropriate sample size for quantitative and qualitative analysis. What does the integration stage of finding involve. Mixed methods design incorporates techniques from qualitative and quantitative methods to answer research questions. In the analysis of each study, we are guided by two sensitizing questions for contemplating a mixed methods study from a qualitative perspective. Yet mixing methods for no good reason other than the sake of it can produce disjointed and unfocussed research, and can severely test the capabilities of researchers.
This brief focuses on using mixed methods to evaluate patientcentered medical home pcmh models. As a methodology, it involves philosophical assumptions that guide the direction of the collection and analysis of data and the mixture of qualitative and quantitative data. This requires using procedures drawn from concurrent forms of data collection. My ebook, the ultimate guide to writing a dissertation in business studies.
Data analysis strategies for mixedmethod evaluation designs. Nieky van veggel asked me, how would i analyse the outcomes of this method. Researchers engaging in mixed methods research need to have a clear sense of the logic and. Integrating quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis while studying patientcentered. The data collection procedure needs to fit the type of mixed methods design in the study.
Mixed methods research definition as a method, it focuses on collecting, analyzing, and mixing both quantitative and qualitative data in a single study or series of studies. Journal of mixed methods research the value of mixed. Develop quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods questions. You have to explain in a brief manner how you are going to analyze the primary data you will collect employing the methods explained in this chapter. Four decisions for mixed method designs creswell, 2003, p.
In addition, mixed methods research requires knowledge of both quantitative and qua. So before you decide to start a mixed methods project, ask yourself whether you really need both types of data. These mixed method designs were used to complement the depth of understanding afforded by the qualitative methods with the breadth of understanding afforded by the quantitative methods n, to explain or elaborate upon the findings of one set of methods usually quantitative with the findings from the other set of methods n 10, or to. Mixed methods research, defined a mixed methods research design is a procedure for collecting, analyzing, and mixing both quantitative and qualitative research and methods in a single.
The appropriateness of these strategies for different kinds of mixed method. Data analysis methods in the absence of primary data collection can involve discussing common patterns, as well as, controversies within secondary data directly related to the research area. Mixed research, or what is referred to as mixed methods research, involves mixing or. Mixed methods social inquirers choose from a full repertoire of methodological options at any number of multiple points in an inquiry process purpose, overall design, methods, sampling, data recording, analysis. The distinctive features of qualitative data collection methods that you studied in chapter 9 are also reflected. While you can combine qualitative and quantitative methods at various points data collection or data analysis.
Broadly speaking, a mixed analysis involves using quantitative and quantitative data analysis techniques within the same study. A theoretical perspective may or may not guide the design. Widely used quant and qual data collection methods 16 table 3. Creswell university of michigan medical school david m. Journal of mixed methods research triangulation and mixed the. Some possible reasons for using mixed methods research design.
Describing and illustrating data analysis in mixed research. The study adopted mixed analysis for data analysis which is guided by either a priori, a posteriori, or iteratively 28. Pdf the challenge in data analysis often lies in taking account of the multidimensionality and complexity of the data and at the same time. Purpose of the study the purpose of this sequential explanatory mixed methods.
Angela harden, phd, professor of community and family health university of east london. Different types of triangulation used in mixed method evaluations 17 table 4. Secondary purpose is use of embedded method to address different research questions or garner. The nature and design of mixed methods research 5 best practices for mixed methods research in the health sciences.
Therefore, it makes sense to have a rationale for doing this, rather than trying to do it for its own sake. Six strategies for mixing methods and linking data in social. The collection and analysis of qualitative data followed by the collection and analysis of quantitative data. Integrating the data during data collection, analysis, or discussion. Data were collected in these designs to provide more data about results from the earlier phase of data collection and analysis, to. Definition mixed methods mixed methods research is a research design with philosophical assumptions as well as methods of inquiry. With the methodological reflection of research practice we evaluate consequences for the field of. The mixed method research design was applied in this study to investigate. Sequential mixed methods data collection strategies involve collecting data in an iterative process whereby the data collected in one phase contribute to the data collected in the next. It simultaneously refers to a process of mixing andor combining qualitative and quantitative data into a single study to provide richer data. Yet, to date, virtually no guidance has been given as to how graphical methods can enhance mixed methods data analyses also referred to as mixed analyses. Sep 17, 2010 techniques designed to combine the results of qualitative and quantitative studies can provide researchers with more knowledge than separate analysis health researchers are increasingly using designs that combine qualitative and quantitative methods, and this is often called mixed methods research.
206 525 465 962 1537 27 913 1592 600 843 503 1365 785 521 898 400 317 824 633 893 320 964 1305 1413 544 170 442 1291 620 579 521 939 804 87 745